HandyHomeMasterReviewHomehttps://handyhomemaster.com/best-water-softener-for-well-water/ Water Softener for Well Water

Finding The Best Water Softener For Well Water In 2022

Last Updated: 06 June 2022

Hard water is a lurking danger that you might not even be aware of. It is highly detrimental to one's health and can cause serious health issues like cardiovascular disease, stunted growth and can increase the onset of Alzheimer’s disease. If the water from your well has high acidity this can greatly influence the absorption of calcium and magnesium – thus having irreversible effects on the health of your bones and mental wellbeing. On top of all that it also damages the internal mechanisms of any home appliance that you own that uses water. A water softener is mandatory in order to remove minerals and other constituents from the well water. Luckily enough the market is very developed, and you will be having a wide array of options when it comes to tackling this issue. Water softeners are highly efficient and have an affordable price tag, so they are the perfect solution.

The purpose of this article is to present you with the best options that are available on the market in 2022. We have taken all relevant facts into consideration when compiling this list to enable you to make an educated purchase that will remove hard water and keep you as healthy as possible. Keep reading our water softener review and comparison table to be better equipped at dealing with hard water.

Handy Home Master created for informational purposes only. Thus, we neither endorse you in any way to buy specific products in our reviews, nor making you act like it’s written in our guides. We are reserving the rights for you to make your personal decision.



Editor-in-Chief of the Handy Home Master
Ease of installation

Best Water Softener For Well Water: Comparison Chart

Best Overall Water Softener for Well Water: AFWFilters Iron Pro 2 Combination water softener & iron filter Review

AFW Filters have been on the market for over 35 years and that is a guarantee to the effectiveness of their water softener filters. The Digital 5600XT Metered Control head comes with a simple yet effective design that removes rust stains caused by ferrous iron and removes scale, white spots caused by water and the scum that is produced from using soap. The design is metered to estimate how much water is used and can regenerate when required. Digital control can perform adjustments in order to provide full capacity or to make sure the least amount of salt is used.

The most important takeaway that comes from this product is that it does not only soften the water but it also actively removes iron. With 15 gallons per minute flow rate and the capability to remove iron, this is an excellent purchase.

Why We Like It

  • Removes manganese that takes the form of slimy dark color stains
  • The outstanding warranty offered for the valve
  • Control head comes with a 5-year warranty
  • Freephone or email tech support instructions for a hassle-free installation
Best For Removing Larger Sediments: iSpring Reusable Whole House Spin Down Sediment Water Filter Review

The filter from ISpring is meant to be the first hurdle the water goes through. It is ideal for removing the larger sediments and rust that might have accumulated in the piping. It also blocks sand and any other type of large particles before the water gets to enter the finer parts of the water filtration system that you have installed for your house. It includes Siliphos that does not allow the scale to settle and is very effective at stopping corrosion from taking over the piping system. The filter should be changed every 3 months to 6 months so that the scale will not be able to build up.

A very sturdy unit that has a heavy-duty glass container and is also very easy to clean. It can withstand heavy use for three to six months it is designed.

Why We Like It

  • Extended manufacturer's warranty
  • The flush-out valve can have a garden hose fitted onto it
  • 20 to 100 psi
  • 40 to 100F indoor only
Best for Removing Iron: DURAWATER 48,000 Grain Water Softener Review

The DURAWATER 48,000 Grain is a complete water softener system that has great efficiency and comes with a Fleck 5600 SXT metered control valve. A fine mesh resin filter is included that is ideal for removing even the tiniest speck of iron. The Pentair Structural tanks are made in the USA along with the Fleck 5600 SXT softener valve. Scan and Service App is included in the purchase and is a brand-new feature from Pentair. Using your phone, you can receive vital information about the water softener. Through the application, you have access to detailed configuration and can access the technical documentation of the unit.

The unit is very easy to install if you follow the instructions. It only takes about two weeks to notice that the iron is completely removed as you will not see rust stains on your toilet or sink.

Why We Like It

  • Safety float is included in the purchase
  • The brine tank comes equipped with an overflow elbow
  • You can figure out what spare parts are required using the Pentair App
  • Troubleshoot manual is available in the packaging as well as through the Pentair App
Best Value with Brine Tank Included: AFWFilters 48,000 Grain Water Softener with brine tank Review

The system designed by AFWFilters is coupled with a well-informed support staff that can assist with any questions and inquiries you might have. The installation instructions are very clear and provide guidelines in order to allow most homeowners to be able to install the system on their own. Video of the installation that includes tips is available on their site. The 1” MNPT thread makes it so that you can easily connect to your plumbing. The bypass valve allows for water to avoid the filter thus remove the need to shut off the main water supply.

With this product you will be able to have clean water from the moment it is installed. The shower and toilets will remain clean for a much longer period than before.


  • Standard brine tank comes equipped with a safety float
  • Installation guidelines are available in the packaging and online
  • The high capacity resin that has a standard 8% crosslink outputs high-quality water softening for an accessible price
  • Digital control that allows adjustments that can maximize capacity


  • Make sure that you do not fill the brine tank with potassium. Unlike salt, potassium will solidify at the bottom of the tank and it will be a pain to dissolve and remove
Best Portable Water Softener: On The Go Portable 16,000 Grain RV Water Softener Review

If you already have an RV and you plan to purchase any accessories for it then this should be at the top of the list, no questions asked. It is the largest compact recreational vehicle water softener available on the market at the moment. It is compact and the design allows for great space-saving. It can be installed almost anywhere, even in the tightest places. We all know that you cannot expect a high-pressure drop in your RV and the On The Go will still be able to output high flow rates.

The only other thing you will require to have perfectly softened water is some plain old table salt. Once the salt is provided the RV water softener works like a charm.


  • Salt addition can be easily made through the large mouth opening
  • The 360-degree swivel makes connecting to the inlet hose simple and fast
  • A standard garden hose can be used to connect the faucet to the RV
  • Can provide clean soft water for up to 40 days


  • The RV water softener system tends to produce higher amounts of sodium. Make sure that you are not on a low sodium diet.
Best for Moderate to Very Hard Water: AFWFilters Fleck Water Softener Digital SXT Metered Whole House System Review
p>Given that it has a 48 000-grain capacity and it is salt-based it means that this system offers by far the best method of softening hard water available on the market. To simplify what it does, it strains water through resin beads and pellets of salt. The whole system is maintenance-free which is a great advantage. The only task you need to fulfill is to make sure that the salt pellets are replaced when needed. It is designed with a medium to a large household in mind.

The system from AFWFilters is a great “set and forget” system. The meter will run based on water usage and you do not need to attend to it.


  • The meter regeneration system works based on the current water flow
  • 5-year warranty on the system
  • 10-year warranty on the tank
  • LCD system is intuitive and very easy to use


  • You need to replace the salt pellets are needed. You can find salt pellets at most department stores or in hardware stores.
Best Water Descaler: Eddy Electronic Water Descaler Review

We are going to look at an alternative to salt water softeners. The descaler from Eddy Water Descalers works by using electromagnetic waves to lower the scaling effects of calcium, magnesium or manganese salts that can be found in hard water. The descaler can perform on both well and tap water and can be used with any type of pipes. The advantage of electronic water softener over the normal water softeners is that you do not need to use salt thus making it environmentally friendly. Using no salt also means lower operating prices and saves time because you do not need to purchase salt every month.

The descaler will perform as promised. It will be great at reducing scaling. It accomplishes the same as a water softener with a much smaller price tag.


  • An instruction manual is supplied with the unit
  • Install and forget business concept, no maintenance needed
  • No plumbing required for the installation
  • 12-month full refund guarantee if you are not fully satisfied with the product


  • The same issue happens for all new technologies that arrive on the market. People need time to become familiar with them and attest to their effectiveness
Best Salt-Free Water Softener: Nuvo H2O Home Water Softener System Review

The next product we have reviewed has offered great results with just a fraction of the price that comes with conventional water softeners. The unit comes with a 20-inch cartridge, but the size of the actual softener stands at 5 x 5 x 24 inches. The NuvoH2O is very effective at saving space and is recommended for smaller households. There is no salt and resin involved so this means that you will need to change the actual cartridge. You can expect to change the cartridge up to four times a year if you have a high-water flow.


  • Great price for a simple water softener
  • You do not need to purchase salt and replace the salt
  • It can accommodate 12-15 gpm flow rate
  • It is very simple and straightforward to install


  • You will need to replace the cartridge after 50 000 gallons. Calculate the water your household uses every day to figure out if this is a good match for your needs
Highest Grain Water Softener: Fleck Grain Water Softener Whole House System Review

This product has a higher price tag because it is designed with high water flow households in mind. Think three-bathroom large households. The unit has the highest grain count from the products we have reviewed so far at 64 000. The water softener from AFWFilters will require about 1 bag of salt every month for a family of four. The brine tank that is included in the price can hold 4 bags at a time. This unit offers peace of mind because it comes with a 10-year warranty on the brine tank and a 5-year warranty on the rest of the system. If you encounter any issues with the system you can expect a speedy response from the customer service lines.

If you have a large household and high-water pressure this is the best choice for you.


  • Metered control head included
  • Huge grain capacity higher than anything we have reviewed
  • The resin is included in the brine tank, all you need to worry about is the salt pellets
  • Fleck 5600SXT Digital control


  • It does not remove Sulphur from the water. An air injection system will be required to remove Sulphur and must be installed prior to the water softener installation

Buyer’s Guide: All You Need to Know About the Best Water Softener for Well Water

Does Well Water Need to be Filtered?

Does Well Water Need to be Filtered

It is mandatory that you filter using well water conditioning system for a host of reasons. Well water that has not been filtered will have a muddy color, an unpleasant smell, and a horrible taste. On top of all that it can cause serious issues to one’s health if not passed through a small water softener. Bacteria and other disease-carrying pathogens are numerous in well water. Well water also contains high amounts of sediments and dirt that must be removed before consumption. Rust, heavy metals, magnesium, and calcium are a risk to your health and to all the appliance you own that function by using water.

Benefits Of Water Softening Systems

Benefits Of Water Softening Systems

There is a wide array of benefits that comes with having softer water by using a compact water softener. Your silverware, glassware, and mirrors will no longer have the white sediments that are caused by calcium deposits. Your hair will be softer, and your skin will be cleaner because your pores won’t have to work overtime. You will be using far less soap and shampoo because the softer water will allow for richer lather. Your clothes will be much softer, and you will have to use far less conditioner than you normally use. Another important advantage of having softer water is the fact that your energy bills will be considerably lower.

How Does a Water Softener Work?

Water softeners work by eliminating calcium and magnesium from your well water using ion exchange. Hard water is placed inside the mineral tank and is then filtered through a bed of resin beads. The plastic beads that are commonly made out of polystyrene have a negative charge of sodium. Calcium and magnesium are minerals that have a positive charge and because opposites attract the calcium and magnesium get trapped inside the resin beads. The sodium ion is released when enough calcium and magnesium has passed through the resin beads.

What Size Water Softener Do I Need?

In order to figure out the size of the water softener filter, you will require we will need to do math. First of all, we have to multiply the number of family members by the gallons of water they each use every day. An average household per person can be considered 80 gallons to make this calculation easier. Once you have figured out the initial results you will need to figure out the hardness of your water by calculating the grains that are present in the water using a water test. This way you will know exactly how many grains must be removed daily thus knowing the exact capacity of the water softener you will need.

How Long Do Water Softeners Last?

This answer greatly depends on the type of the best whole house water softener system you decide to purchase and on the quality of the said water softening system. You can expect a single tank electric water softener to last up to 12 years. The best water softeners for well water can operate well above 20 years if they are well maintained and the resin/salt is changed at the correct time.

How to Choose the Best Water Softener For Well Water


What Size Water Softener Do I Need

The weight of the actual water softener system is relevant only if you are having issues lifting heavy objects. It is also important that you have enough space to install the water filter. When it comes to strictly weight you can expect most water softener systems to be around 50 pounds to 100 pounds.


The water conditioning system for well water is not very large in size. The only thing that will take some relevant space is the brine tank if your system comes equipped with one. Water softeners that do not include a brine tank will take much less space. The average size is somewhere between 15 x 25 x 50 inches for most well water softeners featured on this list.

Flow rate

There are two measurements we have to consider in order to figure out the actual flow rate for a water softener. There is the actual flow rate of water that can be physically pushed through the softener without softening the water and the flow rate that can be pushed through the softener and having it softens the water. The flow rate of the water that can be softened is determined by how much resin is included in the brine tank. The average softener can output about 5 gpm water flow per cubic foot of resin that is inside the well water filter and softener.

Grain capacity

The accurate way to describe softener grain capacity is by cubic feet of resin and the amount of salt required to achieve the said capacity. The efficiency is calculated in grains per pound of salt used. The best water softener for hard well water we have featured on our list range from 16 000 to 64 000 grains. The larger grain capacity the highest the water flow it can soften.


The warranty depends on the type of water softener. The salt-based water softeners all have a 5-year warranty of the system itself and a 10-year warranty for the brine tank. All other types of water softeners tend to have a lifetime warranty.

Ease of installation

Ease of installation

You can install a water softener yourself without the need of a plumber or a handyman. All you need to do is follow the instructions included in the packaging and you can expect the whole process to take between one to three hours. For some water softeners, you might not require any tools and for others, you will require tools that are specified in the instruction manual.


Water softener price depends on the type of water softener and the amount of water you need filtered. They start in the low hundreds and can reach up to 1000 for the best water softener for well water with iron.

Best Water Softener for Well Water Types

Salt-Based Water Softener

Salt-Based Water Softener

The salt-based water softener is by far the most common type of water softener and has the largest traction on the market being used in most households. It uses salt as a filtering system, so the salt has to be constantly added to the brine tank to make sure that the water is properly filtered. We believe that you would be interested in checking out our best whole house humidifier reviews.

Salt-free Water Softener

Salt free water softeners are also known as descale treatments. Salt-free water conditioners will all the minerals present in the water. However, the crystals will not stick to surfaces so you will see a reduction in the scale build-up. The best way to figure what the best option for you is by testing the water after using both methods.

Duo-Tank Softener

Twin tank water softeners have two resin tanks and one brine/salt tank. There is indeed an immediate advantage to duo-tank softeners. When capacity is reached on one of the tanks that system will immediately enable the second tank. This way you maintain soft water under almost all circumstances.

Duo-Tank Softener

Electronic/Magnetic Descaler

Magnetic water treatment is also known as anti-scale magnetic treatment or AMT for short, is a water treatment that reduces the effect of hard water by having it pass through a magnetic field. This an alternative to traditional water softeners that do not use chemicals. You can read about the best water ionizer in our water softener reviews.

Verdict and Our Recommendation for 2022

After compiling the findings that our editors have supplied we have reached the conclusion that the water softener from AFWFilters Iron Pro 2 Combination water softener & iron filter is our choice for the best water softener for well water 2022. The fact that it has an iron filter included that outputs greats results are one of the many reasons we have ranked it first in our water softener for well water review list. We strongly believe that this is the best choice for medium-sized households, and you will have the softest water possible using this water softener from AFWfilters. For more reviews on various household appliances, you can consult HandyHomeMaster.

filters home
Please rate this article
Current rating:
Based on users feedback


Installing the best well water filtration system yourself will reduce the costs of the installation and you can perform the installation at your own pace. If you are replacing the old water softener you can expect the whole task to be done within an hour. If you want to perform a new installation you will need to have some basic plumbing knowledge and a few tools at your disposal. Some pipes might need to be cut in order to align the water softener with the water supply lines.
The average water softener that has 1 cubic foot of resin in the tank should use about 6 to 8 lbs. per regeneration cycle in order to achieve a 24 000-grain capacity.
Yes, they do typically remove a small amount of iron using the well water treatment system. They are however not designed to remove iron from the well water. What you can do is install an iron filter that will remove most if not all the iron. Some of the units on our list come equipped with such an iron filter so that you don’t have to purchase one individually.
The best way to treat a well water softener system is by using a salt and brine-based water softener. They offer the best results on the market and are also the most popular choice for households. In the future, the technology might evolve so that different descalers will be capable of outputting better results but now the salt-based water softeners reign supreme.
How We Tested
We have tested by using our editors and making sure that they live in areas that have hard water. Luckily enough we have found ten of them on the US territory that has issues with hard water. We have provided each of them with one of the water softeners on our list and let them use the water softeners for one month. They have reported back with the findings and we have compiled them all in this article for easy access. You can consult the review list and check the water softener system for well water that you are interested in and see how our editors rate it in the best water softener for well water reviews. You can also check our best electric tankless water heater review if you are in the market for such an appliance.
Share your thoghts
Please fill required fields
Please fill required fields
Please fill required fields